Dearie me, my tuits have been in short supply. It’s been months since I watched this set, and it’s been sitting on my desk giving my slightly peeved looks ever since. But the time has come for me to get it together and type something. So here we go.
Rather than repeat myself, I’ll refer back to my original posts about the episodes, with a few extra thoughts as they occur to me.
Anyway, the Blu-ray version whIch I’m talking about here comes on five discs, and follows the unfortunate lead of recent years in being a bit light on special features. It seems that despite Doctor Who earning loads of money for the BBC in overseas sales and merchandise, it’s still subject to budget restrictions. Or possibly Daleks.
Anyway, let’s head for the episodes.
Deep Breath – I think I said all I need to say about that one at the time, so I’ll move on..
Into the Dalek – Yup, covered that one, too.
Robot of Sherwood – Still deeply, gloriously silly. And if you don’t appreciate a bit of silliness, you’re on the wrong site.
Listen – Events in later episodes make this story even more wibbly-wobbly and timey-wimey. But if… how can..??? And all that sort of thing… And if you think there’s a monster under the bed, it might not be what you’re expecting.
Time Heist – Still good fun on a second watching, even when you know that things that seem to happen might not be happening the way they seem. Includes some characters it would be nice to see again…
The Caretaker – Any story in which the Doctor convinces himself he can blend in with ordinary people is going to offer lots of humour, and this certainly does, along with the Deadly Peril and (of course) running along corridors.
Kill the Moon – Rrrrrrright. This is where I have to go into more detail. You see, this episode was widely criticised, mocked, derided and poked at on the grounds that the “science” was bad. Errr, what? People can deal with an alien who’s now several thousand years old and who can transform into a whole new body when he wears the old one out. They can deal with a bloody time machine that somehow keeps most of its mass in some other dimension or other to prevent it sinking to the centre of any planet it happens to land on. But get one little moon hatching into an alien thingy that leaves behind a fresh moon that’s the same size as the one it hatched out of and people suddenly become experts on exobiology. Apparently eggs can’t do that, so the science is bad and that’s that. Ridickerous!! Quite obviously, it’s a transdimensional alien wossname that only partly exists in our spacetime framework and so has no problem at all rearranging some mass here or there. Or something. Or maybe people need to sop thinking that Doctor Who is hard sf, because it isn’t and never has been….
Mummy on the Orient Express – OK, I’ve calmed down now. This was another good bit of fun, still worked for me.
Flatline – OK, I didn’t hear the “the science is terrible” mob have a go at this one, which is a relief. Good fun, and must have impressed the management, because a character will be returning in this year’s series.
In the Forest of the Night – Anyone hoping for proper actual science should have run away by now, leaving the rest of us to enjoy the fun. It all makes very little sense, but it’s probably some hyper-intelligent transdimensional beings really running the show rather than the trees. Or something. Nice tiger, as you might expect from the title.
Dark Water/Death in Heaven – Well, yes. Missy was so much fun that she’ll be back in the new series, despite having apparently been vaporised. Well, Certain Death and Inescapable Traps were never really a barrier for her previous incarnations, so I think we can look forward to lots more Terrible Plans, attempts to conquer the universe and the Doctor’s hearts. And loads of gratuitous murder and mayhem.
One good thing is the “Behind the scenes” featurettes for each episode. If these look oddly familiar, it’s because they’re the previously online-only Doctor Who Extra episodes. No bad thing to have them here, in much the same way that the old Doctor Who Confidential used to turn up on the DVDs.
There are commentaries for several episodes, some documentaries that show all the signs of having been made for the US market (apparently BBC America can spend money…), which don’t provide much in the way of new information, but are at least mildly diverting.
Buy it for the episodes rather than the extras.